Healing Combat Trauma

"Disposable Heroes" - Washington Times and ABC News Investigates Drug Testing on Veterans

On June 16th, the Washington Times, which has been following the "Chantix harm to veterans" story doggedly, and ABC News, produced an investigative piece called "Disposable Heroes," about the drug testing that takes place on veterans, sometimes with lethal consequences.   That interactive piece is linked here. (Ironically, earlier this week, we posted an entry about veteran' similar exposure, this time from the Vietnam War, that is still coming to light.  That post is linked here.)

Here's the lead from the Washington Times' story, by Audrey Hudson:

The government is testing drugs with severe side effects like psychosis and suicidal behavior on hundred of military veterans, using small cash payments to attract patients into medical experiments that often target distressed soldiers returning from Iraq and Afghanistan...

In one such experiment involving the controversial anti-smoking drug Chantix, the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) took three months to alert its patients about severe mental side effects.  The warning did not arrive until after one of the veterans taking the drug had suffered a psychotic episode that ended in a near lethal confrontation with police.

If you want to find other entries in the Washington Times' extensive coverage of Chantix and veterans, use this link here, which will produce a list of the articles, or go to their website, linked here, and do a search for "Chantix".  Be forewarned, however. Although the information on the website is well worth learning, the Washington Times has an especially cumbersome user interface, irrespective of browser.  Get ready to enable popups, and then, even so, only be able to pull up the stories with great difficulty.  Someone really needs to improve that...)

Going Frantic over Chantix - Anti-Smoking Drug Causes Problems for Veterans with PTSD

An anti-smoking drug, Chantix, prescribed to veterans, including those with PTSD, has been linked to significant health problems:

The Washington Times reported on February 2, "Government regulators said the connection between Pfizer's anti-smoking drug Chantix [Vanericline] and serious psychiatric problems is "increasingly likely." The Food and Drug Administration said it has received reports of 37 suicides and more than 400 of suicidal behavior in connection with the drug."

---

On May 16, the FDA issued a Public Health Advisory, linked here, about the drug, and mentioned -- of particular concern to those with PTSD -- that use of Chantix "may cause worsening of a current psychiatric illness even if it is currently under control and may cause an old psychiatric illness to reoccur." The FDA warned those taking Chantix about the "possibility of severe changes in mood and behavior," as well as about "vivid, strange and unusual dreams" -- problems already for veterans with PTSD. Similarly, the FDA described symptoms that Chantix might cause may include "anxiety, nervousness, tension, depressed mood, unusual behaviors and thinking about or attempting suicide."  Grrrreat.  Apparently, according to the health advisory, problems occurred both while taking Chantix, and during withdrawal.

Approximately a week later, on May 22, the Washington Times again reported that the FAA had banned Chantix for use by its pilots and air traffic controllers, after concerns about its use.

 

NPR Local Affiliate KQED's Story about VA Being Sued over Veterans' Healthcare

According to a story aired today on KQED -- a San Francisco public radio and television station, and NPR affiliate -- Berkeley, California's Disability Rights Advocates recently filed a lawsuit "that could affect thousands of veterans returning from Iraq and Afghanistan. They allege that the Department of Veterans Affairs is unable to provide timely mental health treatment for returning veterans. It describes a backlog of 600,000 claims for vets seeking care — some dating all the way back to the Vietnam War." To listen to the approximately five minute story, click here.  (And yes, this is the lawsuit that's produced the incendiary emails that have lately been in the news, including the infamous "shhh..." one about veterans suicides, which we blogged about earlier, here.)

Editor's Note: For more information about the veterans access to healthcare lawsuit in Federal court, as provided by the Disability Rights Advocates website, click here.

Patriot Hills: A Recreation and Wellness Center for Wounded Warriors Planned for Upstate New York

The Albany Times-Union has an article in Friday's paper, linked here, called "A Bridge from Wartime to Civilian Life: Fundraising begins for Patriot Hills, a planned wellness center for National Guard soldiers."  According to the article, Jeannine Mannarino, 48, a retired Army National Guard master sergeant, and dozens of volunteers are creating a nonprofit group to fundraise a planned $21 million to crate a "wellness and recreation center for wounded warriors in the Adirondack foothills."  The article says Mannarino, who is divorced from her husband, a Vietnam veteran who became "a different person" once he had PTSD, "envisions Patriot Hills of New York as the first Armed Services Recreation Center geared to National Guard members and the treatment of military-related maladies," including PTSD.  As the article mentions, "The concept of combat veterans recovering through recreation and professional therapy is innovative and timely," said Mannarino," and adds,

"Patriot Hills would be a therapeutic mountain resort for National Guard soldiers and others who return from war or are diagnosed with trauma. It would give them access to sports and entertainment, but also counseling in a relaxing environment."

This sounds like a great idea.  The National Guard in particular seems underserved, nationally, and we wish this project and Ms. Mannarino, every success.  It will not be the only initiative of its kind: several private initiatives have sprung up over the last few years, but their current status is unclear.  There's the proposed Veterans' Village in Guerneville, California, which is currently getting opposed by its NIMBY-conscious neighbors; and The Sanctuary for Veterans and Families, envisioned by Stacy Bannerman, author of When the War Came Home: the Inside Story of Reservists and the Families They Leave Behind, which seems to have stalled out, either temporarily or permanently.

The Double Whammy: Women Combat Veterans with PTSD and Military Sexual Trauma

What's blowing up right now -- on the Web -- in terms of searches, within combat trauma and PTSD: definitely this one. People, the VA included, are looking for resources on treating women combat veterans who are victims of Military Sexual Trauma (MST) (see our index to entries discussing that, linked here). 

That means one of two things (prediction coming): either there's a scandal brewing, and about to hit the news, on this topic; or, the VA and others are fairly well bereft of resources and wondering how best to treat sufferers of this problem, who are apparently reaching the VA in greater numbers.  (One possibility: news items like this that show studies recently have shown an unsurprising but nevertheless unfair disparity in care between men and women veterans.)

Unfortunately, this is another case where civilians have a better situation going for them than the troops do.  In the civilian world, women can take their employers to court for providing a sexual harrassing or otherwise hostile work environment, and their victories in this arena put other employers on notice not to go and do likewise.  Sadly, the troops have no such protection.  It's completely a double whammy: combat trauma AND trauma from rape or other sexual crime.  Women servicemembers who've been affected by it say that in their minds, predominantly, the military sexual trauma is even worse than the PTSD, though they often occur together. 

It's clear we don't have a handle yet on treating PTSD; unfortunately, PTSD concerns even more people; and MST is probably further down the list of where resources are focused right now.  But whether through growing public awareness, better reporting, or for whatever reason, if searches are any indication, the VA is in a quandary about how best to treat MST, and even who the experts / what the resources are.  We wish them, and particularly those who have been injured and mistreated in this manner, all the best, and hope the situation resolves positively, and quickly, for our women veterans, who have been doubly injured.

PTSD, Puppies and Misplaced Values - We're Having the Wrong Conversation, America

Now that media coverage of SSgt. Travis Twiggs -- the five times-deployed Marine and gen-u-ine American hero who killed himself recently after a protracted and unsuccessful fight with PTSD -- has safely faded from view, America can go back to talking about what really interests it - like the Marine tossing the puppy off the cliff in Hawaii.  Here's a great quotable quote from Kathie Costos, a senior chaplain with the International Federation of Chaplains and a longtime, tireless advocate for veterans with PTSD, both personally and professionally on her blog, WoundedTimes, linked here.  After noting that a mention of the news update on "that jerk" with the puppy toss sent blog traffic sky-high, Costos said, most quotably -- "I hate the fact a puppy toss gets more attention than a Marine killing himself because the DOD and the VA won't do what they are supposed to do."  Amen, sistah.  (I don't believe that she's talking about the Twiggs case there, specifically, but just in general.)

---

On this blog here, other than news about Travis Twiggs, which people were searching for because they cared about him, what really sends the hit meter aflying is any mention of THTIOKARR -- The Hotness That is Otherwise Known as Rudy Reyes -- who I mention from time to time only because, other than the obvious (hotness!!!), he seems to be an interesting amalgamation of "yin" and "yang" -- the reflective, centered, holistically-minded, nevertheless deadly warrior.  (Sort of the Bruce Lee Lite for our generation, or if Bruce Lee were a veteran, that sort of thing.)  That gives me hope that he's processing his own stuff, whatever that may be, from combat in as effective a way as possible, and being somewhat of a guiding light to others who have shared his experience.  On the other hand, I'm pretty sure people are just searching for photos of Rudy Reyes -- and where they're coming from is often fairly entertaining (defense installations everywhere, and multiple foreign countries, as well as our own.)  I enjoy learning news about Rudy Reyes, however faint, as much as the next person; or cringe over more news about the deranged puppy-tosser, but here's some veterans news we actually SHOULD care about, and it's happening NOW, and it affects us all:

From Brian McGough, at VoteVets, quoting Anne Weismann, general counsel for Citizens for Reponsibility and Ethics in Washington [CREW], in a blog entry linked here:

Today, [Citizens for Responsiblity and Ethics in Washington] CREW received a truly remarkable response from the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) to its Freedom of Information (FOIA) request for documents relating to the VA’s abhorrent practice of under-diagnosing PTSD in veterans to save money. According to the VA, CREW is not entitled to a fee waiver -- meaning it has to pay for the costs of finding and copying responsive documents -- because there is no longer any public interest in this issue! Ignoring the wealth of news articles triggered by CREW’s and VoteVets.org's release of an internal VA email and the congressional hearing that release prompted, the VA claims that any records CREW requests “would not reveal anything new.”

(Those VA emails are at the heart of a Federal court case in San Francisco, put on by two veterans' rights groups suing the government over better care.  The judge in the case certainly seems to think they're relevant -- perhaps there are more, and that's why the requests were spurned.  Hey, can they even DO that?  They shouldn't be able to...)

But those don't seem to be the topics we're "alarmed" about -- how PTSD from combat trauma can be so bad it can kill you, and how the healthcare system in place to tend to veterans when they come back needs to do a better job of fully taking care of them.  No, instead we're searching for what amounts to celebutainment, and leaving the weightier matters -- for whom? If not us, who? It better be us, and all of us -- there isn't actually anyone else but us who oughta be caring, and who it concerns.  You don't have to actually put on combat boots to "get" that veterans are being underserved, particularly in the area of healthcare (TBI, PTSD, MST) and benefits (foreclosures! the GI Bill), and that it's up to us to care enough about it, that we do something about it, as a nation.  We CAN do that.  Otherwise, the note scrawled on the white board in the photograph, above, in Iraq, is really going to be our epitaph.  America isn't at war -- we're at the mall.

Editor's Note: Sign the petition for the new GI Bill, here. Love the slogan: "We sent them to war.  Why can't we send them to college?"  Why, indeed.

Israeli Military's Proactive Plan for Identifying and Treating Soldiers Who Have PTSD

Here in the U.S., in our usual myopic way, we can get bogged down in the news about returning servicemembers with combat trauma and PTSD and forget just how many other countries in the world have struggled with this problem as well, and often found their own solutions.  Internationally, Japan, Israel, Australia, England and Canada frequently search the Internet for news about who's doing what, and what's working, for treating PTSD worldwide -- according to data from Google's analytical trends.  Today, the Jerusalem Post has an article about how Israel's Defense Ministry is about to unveil a plan for evaluating and treating soldiers systematically who have been exposed to PTSD as part of their military service.  (The article in question is linked here.)  Their expectation is that 2,500 Israelis suffer from PTSD, in a country where military service is compulsory, and conflicts in the region frequently boil over into sustained violence. 

The significance of the Israeli announcement is that the soldiers will be treated according to a "set psychological and medical format," meaning systematically and methodically.  Their understanding is that PTSD treatment succeeds better if initiated earlier, so evaluating all soldiers soon after military service will increase the chances of favorable treatment outcomes.  According to the article, three years ago the military started thinking through how to create a protocol that would involve every soldier, and optimize chances of finding and treating PTSD.  The protocol was developed by Zeev Waisman and Dr. Dan Dolfin.

Two interesting comments from the article express a vision that the U.S. might be wise to emulate:

"A soldier who comes out of battle will immediately be evaluated and we will see what type of treatment he needs," Waisman said. "Nothing is done today in a regulated fashion and we want all treatment to be according to a protocol."

The process begins by inserting the soldier's profile into the system which will then offer several courses for treatment that could include medicines, psychological therapy, family therapy, sex therapy and others. Waisman said that the Ministry of Defense hoped to convince other organizations to adopt the new format which will be evaluated in two years.

Stateside, it's not even clear that the various branches of the Armed Forces share a similar protocol for identifying and treating PTSD -- most likely, they do not.  With far more servicemembers at risk for PTSD than the Israelis have, we could do worse than to imitate what the Israeli Defense Ministry is putting into action as a plan to deal with PTSD, and return exposed servicemembers to better mental and emotional health.

"Give an Hour" Helps Fill Veterans Counseling Gap

Give an Hour -- the foundation that matches member psychogists and counselors with veterans and their families in need of counseling at no charge -- to fill the currently unmet gap in mental health services, has been in the news recently.  (You can learn more about Give an Hour's founder, Barbara V. Romberg, Ph.D., in her bio, linked here). It's truly fantastic to see this public-spirited act of service on the part of Give an Hour; at the same time, it's a shame that private industry, so to speak, has to jump in to fill the unmet gap of mental health care -- the need for which care is an entirely predictable "soft cost" of going to war.  Nevertheless, good stuff, and very altruistic and forward-thinking on the part of Dr. Romberg and her organization.

From a press release:

The American Psychiatric Foundation, Lilly Foundation And Give An Hour Join Forces To Provide Mental Health Care To Iraq And Afghanistan Veterans

Heeding the call of a growing public health crisis -- the unmet mental health needs of returning soldiers and their families -- Give an Hour (GAH) and the American Psychiatric Foundation (APF) announced a major expansion of a nationwide effort to help U.S. veterans returning from Iraq and Afghanistan.

GAH and APF, the philanthropic and educational arm of the American Psychiatric Association (APA), will be using a $1 million grant from the Lilly Foundation to recruit and educate volunteer mental health professionals, who will become part of a network aiming to bridge the gap in mental health services for soldiers returning from service, as well as their families. Among troops returning from Iraq and Afghanistan, approximately 40 percent of soldiers, a third of Marines, and half of the National Guard members report psychological problems, but mental health services are in short supply.

"This all-volunteer effort provides badly needed support to help our veterans, many of whom come home with mental health needs," said U.S. Representative Steve Buyer (R-Indiana), Ranking Member, House Committee on Veterans' Affairs. "I applaud the hard work of Give an Hour, the American Psychiatric Foundation, and the Lilly Foundation, which are stepping up to help those who have selflessly served."

Efforts will be made to create a large, national, volunteer network over the next three years to address postwar mental health issues such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), traumatic brain injury (TBI), drug abuse, anxiety and depression.

"This grant will allow us to get out the message that help is available. We want to normalize what our military personnel and their families are experiencing and support the sacrifices that they are making by providing critical mental health support at no cost," said Barbara V. Romberg, Ph.D., founder and president of GAH. "We will be educating the military community and broader public about these mental health needs in hope of helping veterans keep their lives and families intact."

GAH is recruiting mental health professionals to volunteer one hour each week for a minimum of one year to provide direct services in person, by phone or in consultation with schools and community organizations that serve the military community. Services are wide-ranging and include marital and family therapy, substance abuse counseling and treatment for PTSD. APF brings strong ties to the psychiatric community and is actively encouraging psychiatrists to join the network.

"This grant will help us reach our goal of recruiting 10 percent of the 400,000 mental health professionals in the United States by 2015 to assist in this effort," said Dr. Richard K. Harding, M.D., president of the APF. "It is an ambitious goal, but we are confident it can be achieved."

The Department of Defense (DoD) is making an unprecedented attempt to encourage personnel to seek mental health treatment, but a significant increase in demand, in some areas, has forced the rationing of services, created long waiting lists and limited individual counseling sessions. In addition, some members of military families such as parents, siblings and unmarried partners do not qualify for care through the Veterans Administration or DoD but are affected nonetheless by the mental health of the veteran.

"We're privileged to be able to give something back to our troops, but we know there's still much more to be done," said Steven Paul, M.D., executive vice president for science and technology and president of Lilly Research Laboratories. "Lilly is fully committed to assuring that the best possible medicinal treatments are available, but unfortunately, we also know that having access to the best care -- in this case mental health services -- is essential."

About Give an Hour
Give an Hour is a nonprofit 501(c)(3), founded in September 2005 by Dr. Barbara V. Romberg, a psychologist in the Washington, D.C., area. The organization's mission is to develop national networks of volunteers capable of responding to both acute and chronic conditions that arise within our society. Currently, GAH is dedicated to meeting the mental health needs of the troops and families affected by the ongoing conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan. Give an Hour now has approximately 1,200 providers across the nation and continues to recruit volunteer mental health professionals to its network. For more information or to volunteer to become part of the effort, please visit http://www.giveanhour.org.

About The American Psychiatric Foundation
The American Psychiatric Foundation is the charitable and educational subsidiary of the American Psychiatric Association. The mission of the foundation is to advance understanding that mental illnesses are real and can be effectively treated. For more information, please visit the foundation's web site at http://www.psychfoundation.org.

About Lilly
Lilly, a leading innovation-driven corporation, is developing a growing portfolio of first-in-class and best-in-class pharmaceutical products by applying the latest research from its own worldwide laboratories and from collaborations with eminent scientific organizations. Headquartered in Indianapolis, Ind., Lilly provides answers -- through medicines and information -- for some of the world's most urgent medical needs. Additional information about Lilly is available at http://www.lilly.com.

From Give an Hour's website:

Our Mission
Our mission is to develop national networks of volunteers capable of responding to both acute and chronic conditions that arise within our society. Our first target population is the U.S. troops and families who are being affected by the current military conflicts in Afghanistan and Iraq. Give an Hour is asking mental health professionals nationwide to literally give an hour of their time each week to provide free mental health services to military personnel and their families. Research will guide the development of additional services needed by the military community, and appropriate networks will be created to respond to those needs. Individuals who receive services will be given the opportunity to give an hour back in their own community.

Our Focus
Our organization is currently focusing on the psychological needs of military personnel and their families because of the significant human cost of the current conflicts. Over 1.6 million troops have been deployed in Afghanistan, Iraq, and the Persian Gulf since September 11, 2001. Nearly 550,000 of these troops have been deployed more than once. According to the U.S. Department of Defense, as of May 15, 2008, nearly 4,600 American troops have died in Iraq and Afghanistan. Roughly 32,875 U.S. troops have been injured during these conflicts.

In addition to the physical injuries sustained, countless servicemen and servicewomen have experienced psychological symptoms directly related to their deployment. According to a RAND report released in April 2008, over 18 percent of troops who have served in Iraq and Afghanistan--nearly 300,000 troops--have symptoms of post-traumatic stress or major depression. At the same time, about 19 percent of service members reported that they experienced a possible traumatic brain injury. And let us not forget: millions of Americans belong to the families of these servicemen and servicewomen. Spouses, children, parents, siblings, and unmarried partners of military personnel are all being adversely affected by the stress and strain of the current military campaign.

Our military leaders are well aware of the human cost of this campaign. Indeed, they are attempting to address the psychological needs of the troops through a variety of programs within the military culture. Unfortunately, the tremendous number of people affected makes it impossible for the military to respond adequately to the mental health needs in its greater community. For example, according to the RAND study, only 43 percent of troops reported ever being evaluated by a physician for their head injuries. Moreover, returning combat veterans suffering from depression, anxiety, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) are not routinely seeking the mental health treatment they need. RAND also reports that only 53 percent of service members with PTSD or depression sought help over the past year.

A major barrier preventing military personnel from seeking appropriate treatment is the perception of stigma associated with treatment. Many fear that seeking mental health services will jeopardize their career or standing. Others are reluctant to expose their vulnerabilities to providers who are often military personnel themselves, given the military culture’s emphasis on strength, confidence, and bravery. Servicemen and servicewomen might be more inclined to seek help if they know that the services provided are completely independent of the military. By providing services that are separate from the military establishment, we offer an essential option for men and women who might otherwise fail to seek or receive appropriate services.

We are also offering services to parents, siblings, and unmarried partners who are not entitled to receive mental health benefits through the military. Although these individuals may have access to mental health services through other means, they are less likely to seek the help they need and deserve if that help is difficult to find or costly. Our goal is to provide easy access to skilled professionals for all of the people affected by the current war. The participating mental health professionals offer a wide range of services including individual, marital, and family therapy; substance abuse counseling; treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder; and counseling for individuals with traumatic brain injuries. Whether it is a young military wife who is anxious because her four-year-old has had nightmares since her husband’s deployment or a father who is struggling to cope with his son's loss of a leg as a result of an explosion in Iraq, both will receive the assistance they need to move through their experience. The healthier the support system for the returning troops, the lower the risk of severe or prolonged dysfunction within these military families.

Our Plan
Give an Hour is reaching out to the military community in several ways. As a member of America Supports You, a Department of Defense program that provides opportunities for citizens to show their support for the U.S. Armed Forces, we are identifying individuals involved in post-deployment processing of returning troops. We are developing collaborative relationships with the commanding officers of returning troops so that these officers are aware of and comfortable with the services we provide. We are also working closely with a number of veterans service organizations to promote our services directly to the family members of troops. Furthermore, we are working with individuals affiliated with Walter Reed Army Medical Center in Bethesda, Md. We are also collaborating with the Veterans Administration to distribute information about our services through Vet Centers across the country.

Finally, we are promoting our services to the military community and the public through a media campaign that includes print, television, and radio coverage. In fact, our founder and president, Dr. Barbara Romberg, has been interviewed in national media outlets from the Washington Post to NPR's Diane Rehm Show, Ladies' Home Journal, and HD Net's World Report.

Give an Hour recruits mental health professionals in several ways. We have been endorsed by the American Psychiatric Association and the National Association of Social Workers and are seeking endorsements from other major mental health organizations. Only licensed mental health professionals are included in the network. Licenses are verified. Non-licensed pastoral providers may be included in the network as long as they meet other criteria, including membership in professional organizations. In addition to coordinating with national organizations, we also recruit mental health professionals through professional publications and Web sites.

As of May 2008 we have a redesigned Web site, expanded to include materials to guide visitors seeking services as well as reference materials to inform mental health professionals. Only mental health professionals trained and experienced to work with trauma victims will identify themselves as available to work with soldiers who have experienced combat. We are working with experts in the trauma field to prepare materials for our Web site and to find appropriate mental health professionals for recruitment.

The Eli Lilly and Company Foundation recently awarded Give an Hour, in partnership with the American Psychiatric Foundation, a major grant that will allow us to spread our message to the leaders of the mental health community in every state. 

We are recruiting volunteers from a number of organizations and institutions as well as through our Web site to assist us in the implementation of our program. Volunteers from retired military personnel to members of military families to concerned civilians throughout thte country are helping Give an Hour. Volunteers are checking licenses, distributing brochures, and coordinating community partnership opportunities for those troops and family members interested in giving back an hour to their own community.

Our Vision
Our primary focus will always be to attend to those in need by linking them to individuals in our society best equipped to respond effectively. In addition, we will develop research and educational programs to further promote the value and importance of a new kind of volunteerism. We hope to encourage an increase in shared responsibility for those citizens who are su